Review of the Saturday, October 24, 2026 evening preview performance at The Hayes Theatre in New York City. A Second Stage production. Starring Maxim Chlumecky, Kevin Del Aguila, David Patrick Kelly, Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer, Nathan Levy, Ruthie Ann Miles, Zane Phillips and Ahmad Simmons. Revised book and lyrics from the original by Tom Jones. Music by Harvey Schmidt. Orchestrations by Sam Davis. Scenic design by Jason Sherwood. Costume design by Linda Cho. Lighting design by Jen Schriever. Sound design by Nevin Steinberg. Musical direction by Rick Hip-Flores. Choreography and direction by Christopher Gattelli. 2 hours 15 minutes including one intermission.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I'll admit I was a tad concerned about seeing a third preview of a new production - that same scenario for The Rocky Horror Show is still leaving a bad taste in my mouth. But from the moment I sat down, I had a feeling the show was in a good place already. You see, upon entering, the stage was set simply as The Fantasticks is known for. In fact, it was a touching tribute to the indelible mark left by the original record-breaking production: a simple black curtain, a hand painted sign with the name of the show held up by two thin sticks, a piano and a harp. Downstage, a storage box labelled "Sullivan Street Playhouse" sat almost expectantly. Then the overture started, just the harp and piano as always (and played by two gentlemen who bore an uncanny resemblance to authors Tom Jones (revised book and lyrics) and Harvey Schmidt (music)). The mute comes in and magically transforms the stage into a bright, more fully appointed space, now with a somewhat fancier sign and a storage box labelled "Hayes Theater." The orchestra, now quadrupled in size, swells as the overture continues, and the audience applauds loudly in appreciation. And it only got better from there!
Although this version is much bigger (relatively) than the off-Broadway classic, it is, as it has always been, a very simple production. Across the board, great care has been made to maintain simplicity, so as to keep the focus on the characters and themes. This includes the beautifully expanded orchestrations by Sam Davis, who has made the score remain quaint, but now with a full, lush sound. Nevin Steinberg's exquisite sound design is clear as a bell and perfectly balances the chamber orchestra and the cast of eight.
What I particularly enjoyed about the primary design elements is the Everyman feeling of everything paired with an exciting theatricality. At once we are reminded that this is a very human story in the guise of a play. Linda Cho's costumes are pretty straightforward, with the parents and the lovers in modern garb that differentiates them, but also subliminally shows their commonality. The theatrical characters are, of course, distinctly more dramatic - particularly the two old Thespians whose garb ranges from commedia del arte to vagabond to high farce.
Then there is Jason Sherwood's delightfully old school setting, a false theater wall - with doors and windows that transform with the different scenes - surrounds a raised platform full of fun surprises. But it is Jen Schriever's fanciful lighting design that really stuck with me. A kaleidescope of ever-changing colors takes us from the highs of young love to the depths of despair and everything in between. Even the bare bulbs that line the stage are magical!
There is absolutely nothing I could add to any discourse about this timeless book and score - whole volumes have been written about it. But I will say that Jones' desire to update the piece with a same-sex romantic couple and gender-swapped parents was a great way to update the work without really changing it. His tweaks to the lyrics and the book were clearly a labor of love that serve more to say that love is love, family is family, than a chance to just hit that "woke" button. (It is proudly and humbly woke...).
All of that said, with just eight characters and no scenery to hide behind, no matter how good the creative elements are, it would be meaningless without a top notch cast. No worries here. As the traveling players, the legendary David Patrick Kelly and the soon-to-be legendary Kevin Del Aguila fit together like hand in glove, yin and yang. Their roles involve quite a range of acting styles and physical comedy. Even with only three previews under their belts, they were terrific, and one imagines how effortlessly funny they will be after even more performances. I was not prepared for just how wonderful Ahmad Simmons was as The Mute. His being a stellar dancer (he was amazing in Illinoise and West Side Story) wasn't surprising, but he was absolutely mesmerizing to watch; every move, every expression spoke wordless volumes. And our mischievous narrator, aka El Gallo, is played with effortless charm or downright sexiness by Zane Phillips, here making a swoon-worthy Broadway debut. He commands the stage in such a captivating way, you can't stop looking at him or listening carefully to his booming yet gentle voice (the classic "Try to Remember" is in very capable hands). Here's to seeing him in many more shows!
Comedy gold is mined by the outwardly lamenting, secretly conniving mothers, who have constructed a devious plan to keep their children apart in order to bring them together. These two are in the deft hands of Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles. (Their first act duet, "Never Say No" is a genuine showstopper.) I am thrilled that Ms. Kritzer has reined in her considerable penchant for playing to the rafters; here her even-handed understatement makes her even funnier. Meanwhile, getting the chance to see Ms. Miles cut loose and be truly hilarious is a real gift for the audience. There really must be no acting style she can't master, and she seems to be having the time of her life, too!
Finally, as the central pair of young lovers kept apart, brought together and torn apart, both Maxim Chlumecky and Nathan Levy share a palpable chemistry, and have now joined the new generation of wonderful actors to watch. While both have previously begun their Broadway resumes, it is with this show that both have come into their own. Chlumecky gives off such a heady mix of awkwardness and bravado that the audience falls for his character as quickly as Levy's character does. Similarly, you can't help but fall for Levy's coy playfulness that masks an all too familiar insecurity. As silly as the pretense of the story is, both make sure we are captivated. And did I mention their voices? Wow! How nice to hear genuine Broadway voices full of character and emotional nuance instead of the now expected American Idol style of power riffing for applause. Each also shines in their Act Two "production numbers," showing off their triple threat energy.
Recent Tony-winner Christopher Gatelli has managed to bring a classic to the modern stage with such clarity and reverence that today's audience can find so much to love in a fresh way, while purists can certainly relax happily knowing that their beloved chestnut is as wonderful as ever. His ability to ground the piece while heightening the whimsy is remarkable, as is his ability to coax out nuances in the array of acting styles the script demands.
I'm tempted to say that this is a Fantasticks for the 21st century, but that undercuts the truth. Better put, this is a Fantasticks for the ages. And that is, indeed, fantastic.
📸: J. Marcus







No comments:
Post a Comment