Tuesday, April 7, 2026

Review: Cats: The Jellicle Ball

Review of the Saturday, March 28, 2026 matinee preview performance at the Broadhurst Theatre in New York City. Starring Andre de Shields, Ken Ard, "Tempress" Chastity Moore, Sydney James Harcourt, Dudney Joseph, Jr., Robert "Silk" Mason, Kya Azeen, Bryson Battle, Baby Byrne, Jonathan Burke, Dava Huesca, Junior LaBeija, Leiomy, Primo Thee Ballerino, Xavier Reyes, Nora Schell, Bebe Nicole Simpson, Emma Sofia, Garnet Williams and Teddy Wilson, Jr. Music by Andrew Lloyd Webber. Lyrics by T.S. Eliot. Based on Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats by T.S. Eliot. Scenic design by Rachel Hauck. Costume design by Qween Jean. Lighting design by Adam Honoré. Projection design by Brittany Bland. Sound design by Kai Harada. Magic by Paul Kieve. Choreography by Omari Wiles and Arturo Lyons. Direction by Zhail Levingston and Bill Rauch. 2 hours 45 minutes including one intermission.

When all is said and done, no matter the concept, Cats is still Cats. Except now, it is also so much more. 

In the early 80s, the show was an absolute phenomenon. You weren't a Broadway fan if you didn't see it. Heck, you weren't even considered cultured if you weren't seen at the junkyard. It was a weekly who's who that made the columns that reported who was there. But, like almost everything in American culture, its shelf-life was limited, and soon it was an easy joke on SNL and elsewhere. "Now and Forever" the ads said, and people couldn't help but countdown to its demise. Many of us ardent Cats fans sort of went into hiding about our love for Old Deuteronomy's tribe. 

  

Lately, the grip on re-staging it as a duplicate of the original has begun to loosen. The revival a few years ago started to push at the boundaries. Someone else had a hand in the choreography!? "Blasphemy!" purists screamed. But now, the kitties in their skin tight leotards with their yarn-made tails and fur patches have popped up at a rodeo and a circus instead of a junkyard. Then came 
Zhail Levingston, Bill Rauch, Omari Wiles and Arturo Lyonswho as directors and choreographers, threw everything we thought we knew about the show out with the kitty litter, and brought the felines to the Ballroom. 

What is remarkable about the whole thing - and there is a lot that is remarkable - is that the concept not only fits perfectly, but somehow clarifies and enlightens the classic. That it is done with almost no lyric changes (a few gender pronouns have been changed), and every note of Andrew Lloyd Webber's iconic score is played as written (though a lot has been added), makes it all the more extraordinary. The connection between Grizabella and her unwitting protege Sillabub is deeper and adds much to the story. Macavity has never made more sense. And some fun, modern touches bring Skimbleshanks into the 21st Century. (No specific spoilers here.) But the biggest change that comes with the concept is this: in the original, we were seeing people as cats; in Cats: The Jellicle Ball, we finally see the cats as people. It is an important and revelatory distinction. 

The show, which opened on Broadway last night, now features the tagline "Come One. Come All." It is emblematic of this production, which, at its core is all about inclusion. Everyone is indeed welcome to the Jellicle Ball, no matter their race, gender or sexuality. That, in and of itself, makes this an important production during these appalling times when inclusion is a point of division instead of unification. And this is exactly why this take on the piece works so perfectly. In case you know little or nothing about Ballroom, you needn't worry about "getting it." Though I'd highly recommend the documentary film, Paris Is Burning, directors Levingston and Rausch (along with Brittany Bland's exciting projection design) tell us everything we need to know about the genre. And, wow, is it exciting!

Presented as a series of competitions, each cat tells their story, then their cat-egory (pun intended and used frequently in the show) is announced and a cat or two joins the current kitty in a runway (catwalk?) dance off. Trophies are awarded and the audience goes collectively nuts... the energy... literally spine-tingling... Not to worry, just as in the original, they are each still trying to get Old Deuteronomy to choose them for a trip to the Heavyside Layer. Here the head of the tribe is played by the sublimely regal Andre de Shields, whose entrance requires a standing ovation. We must, of course, give this living legend (both actor and feline) his due. It's funny that I realized as the evening went on that as each cat finished, I looked right at him to see his reaction. No one holds court like O.D..

Andre de Shields (left) and Ken Ard (right)

Each member of the company, culled from the worlds of Broadway, drag and ballroom, contributes their breathtaking skill sets so generously that the whole thing feels really authentic, so organic, that the outside world disappears and every ounce of energy in the room creates its own electricity. There's original Broadway cast member Ken Ard who keeps the ball rolling from one of the boxes as D.J. Griddlebone. As a fan of the show and Broadway history, this inclusion pleases me greatly. Dudney Joseph, Jr. takes his M.C. duties very seriously as Munkustrap. A cat, that in every production I've seen, has always captured my heart and senses is Victoria, the white cat/kitten; in Baby Byrne's hands, Victoria is memorable in all the best ways, her runway skills are utter perfection. 

(left to right) Junior LaBeija, Bryson Battle and Emma Sofia

A literal Ballroom Legend - he created a House and is featured in the documentary - Junior LaBeija makes it clear why he has such status when he holds us captive and hanging on every word as "Gus" the Theatre Cat (with a loving assist from Bryson Battle's Jellylorum). As cat burglars Mungojerie and Rumpleteazer, Jonathan Burke and Dava Huesca are a delightful pair of mischief makers with song and dance skills in abundance. Nora Schell's Bustopher Jones is the sexiest take on the role I've ever seen (who knew?), and Emma Sofia's playful take on Skimbleshanks - now a Metro conductor - had me grinning the whole time she was on stage.

There were five performances that really stood out for me. First, there was Javier Reyes as Jennyanydots, a role I've always enjoyed, but here, was just so sensational. Then there was Leiomy as Macavity, who was simply divine and totally thrilling - and her purse...!!! Next was the most limber and leggy Mistoffeles of Robert "Silk" Mason, a superb dancer and appropriately mesmerizing presence. Now I know The Rum Tum Tugger is always a popular favorite, but I could always take it or leave it depending on who played it, but here Sydney James Harcourt's (above left) take on the curious cat is next level sexy, charming and hard to take my eyes off. He oozes charm, of course, but the details of his performance when he's on the periphery are what really seals it - the Tugger is a randy cat, but also very protective and loyal.

Finally, there is star-turn by "Tempress" Chastity Moore (right) as Grizabella, heartbreaking as the faded glamour cat, fierce in protecting her dignity, lonely but clinging to hope, and glorious as she is chosen and "reborn," restored to her full former state of beauty. Her "Memory" is one for the books, stirring and powerfully sung. Her ascension to the Heavyside Layer is a stunning one, which has to be seen to be believed. Brava!

It is, perhaps not surprising that the technical elements of this production are 
as brilliant as this fresh take on a legendary mega-musical. It's not over-sized garbage or a giant tire this time, but it does take over the theater, with onstage seating, a runway that goes out into the orchestra seats, with tables and banquettes and full use of the boxes. Credit for all of that goes to one of my favorite set designers ever, Rachel Hauck, who strikes the perfect balance between complete immersion and honoring the theater space. Adding to that are the previously mentioned projections that appear all over the Broadhurst, and the gloriously technicolor club lighting of Adam Honoréthe top tier club level sound of Kai Haradaand the visual feast that is the costume design of Qween Jean. Every single thing about this production is fresh and exciting, reminiscent of that same feeling when the original opened over forty years ago.

Which brings me back to the direction of Levingston and Rauch, which is so all-encompassing and so thrillingly staged it is really a brand new show. I feel like I learned a few things and was welcomed
 into a new family. But I also loved the touches that they included to pay tribute to the history of the piece. Again no spoilers here, but pay attention to the Overture. The Broadway fan in me felt seen and recognized. And the beautiful tribute to the history (and future) of Ballroom at the start of act two - "The Moments of Happiness" - produced sniffles throughout the house. Even the dazzling choreography of Wiles and Lyons put in more than a few Easter eggs from the Gillian Lynne iconic movement. I have to believe that Dame Gillian would have wholeheartedly adored the Jellicle Ball number if nothing else. (I know I did - I'd pay full admission just to see that again.)

This is truly a "Come One. Come All" musical - not only does it have a Ballroom Culture Consultant (N'yomi Allure Stewart), it has a Sensitivity Specialist (Ann James) and a Gender Consultant (Josephine Kearns). They really have put their money where their mouth is, and we are all the better for it. 

"Now and Forever" no longer feels like a threat. It feels like a promise kept.

📸: M. Murphy, E. Zimmerman 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...