Broadway Games: Double Trouble in 2025

Overall, 2025 was a busy year on the stage. For some actors, it was really a busy year. Several actors appeared in two different productions this year nearly over.

Broadway Games:

Double Trouble in 2025

DIRECTIONS: Name each actor described below. Some of these are tricky!

1. He began 2025 as Marty McFly in Back to the Future and ends the year as J.D. in Heathers: The Musical.
2. He first co-starred as Skeets Miller in Floyd Collins, then followed that Tony-nominated turn with the title role in Bat Boy: The Musical.
3. She plays the kooky guidance counselor in Heathers: The Musical, but left that show briefly to play Meredith Parker in Bat Boy: The Musical.
4. She appeared this year as Diana in the PBS presentation of the West End production of Next to Normal, and currently appears as Mother in Ragtime.
5. He appeared this year as Gabe in the PBS presentation of the West End production of Next to Normal, and currently makes his Broadway debut as Orpheus in Hadestown.
6. He plays the geeky husband of Helen in Death Becomes Her, but left that show briefly to play Dr. Parker in Bat Boy: The Musical.
7. She made her Broadway debut as Juliet Capulet in Romeo + Juliet, then made her West End debut as Eva Peron in Evita.
8. He made his Broadway debut as Arty Greene and famously as understudy for Joe Gillis in Sunset Blvd., then made his West End debut as Che in Evita.
9. This guy left the title role in The Great Gatsby to star in the title role in Floyd Collins. Now he's back in Gatsby.
10. She played the title role in Gypsy, and now she's back on Skid Row as Audrey in Little Shop of Horrors.
11. He played Herbie to Audra's Rose in Gypsy, and now he's co-starring with June Squibb in Marjorie Prime.
12. He died twice in 2025, first as Elmer McCurdy in Dead Outlaw, then as Rick Taylor in Bat Boy: The Musical.
13. He started 2025 as H.T. Carmichael in Floyd Collins, but these days he's deep in the cold war as Walter in Chess.
14. Earlier this year, he appeared with Bernadette Peters in Stephen Sondheim's Old Friends, and is now playing a floating craps game as Sky Masterson in the DC revival of Guys and Dolls with Julie Benko.
15. She was part of the original cast of The Outsiders as Cherry Valance's understudy, but left that show to play another high schooler, Ivy Watkins, in John Proctor is the Villain.