If you are looking to trade, the cards we need are all the way at the bottom of this page. Make us an offer! If you want to buy some to fill in your collection, check out our lists below. We have cards from the Moulin Rouge! and Beetlejuice Series, The Prom , the Megamix, Autumn 2017, Spring 2018, Autumn 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2022 collections. Buy from one collection or mix it up!
All cards are out of pack. Each card is in new, excellent condition, and has been stored in a smoke-free environment and in a box that prevents bending.
RARE CARDS: $5.00 each
SUPER RARE: $12.00 each
2024 CARD SERIES
CORE - Actors
Ana Gastyer Christian Hoff Cole Escola Eden Espinosa Jinkx Monsoon
Joshua Boone Joy Woods Julie Benko Kecia Lewis Kyle Selig
Megan Hilty Ryan Vasquez Sky Lakota-Lynch
CORE - Writers/Composers/Directors/Choreographers
Christopher Durang Dolly Parton Shaina Taub
Schele Williams
CORE - Shows
Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club Gutenberg! The Musical! Once Upon a Mattress (2024)
Starlight Express Stereophonic Suffs The Notebook The Outsiders
RARE - Squigs' Busy Spring 2024
Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club Suffs Once Upon a Mattress (2024)
RARE - Off-Broadway
All the Devils Are Here
RARE - Theatre Lore
The Public Theater The Scottish Play
2023 CARD SERIES
CORE - Actors
Abby Mueller Alex Newell Andrew Burnap Annaleigh Ashford Anna Uzele Arian Moayed Arielle Jacobs Ben Platt Clyde Alves Colton Ryan
Fredie Walker-Brown Jelani Remy John Behlmann John Leguizamo
Jonathan Groff Josh Gad Katie Finneran Katie Rose Clark Krystal Joy Brown
Laura Bell Bundy Laura Linney Lindsay Mendez Mario Cantone
Melba Moore Micaela Diamond Sean Allan Krill Sean Hayes Thom Sesma Wayne Brady Will Swensen
CORE - Writers/Composers
Amber Ruffin Ahrens & Flaherty Matthew Lopez
Sharon Washington Tom Stoppard
CORE - Directors/Choreographer
Coming Soon!
CORE - Shows
& Juliet Ain't No Mo Almost Famous Camelot (2023)
Here Lies Love Life of Pi Once Upon a One More Time
Prima Facie Shucked Some Like It Hot Sweeney Todd (2023)
The Bridges of Madison County Topdog/Underdog (2022)
CORE - Lights of Broadway
Al Hirschfeld Theatre Lena Horne Theatre Vivian Beaumont Theater
RARE - Designers/Music
Emilio Sosa
Don Sebesky
RARE - Honors/Golden Age
John McMullen Phantom Ends Run
Ethel Shutta
RARE - If It Only Runs a Minute/Off-Broadway
Titanique
RARE - Broadway Lore/BroadWay With Words
David Belasco Olive Thomas
SUPER RARE
Foil - Back to the Future's DeLorean
Lenticular - Sweeney Todds
Giving Back - J. Harrison Ghee
2022 CARD SERIES
CORE - Actors
A.J. Shively Adrianna Hicks Alli Mauzey Amy Spanger Andrew Garfield
Anika Larsen Beanie Feldstein Beth Leavel Brittney Johnson
Christine Baranski Brian D'Arcy James Darren Criss David Josefsberg
Fantasia Barrino Forrest McClendon Gavin Creel James Naughton
Jared Grimes Jeanna deWaal Jim Walton Julia Murney Mark Jacoby
K. Todd Freeman Kristolyn Lloyd Malcolm Getz Michael McCormick
Nik Walker Quentin Earl Darrington Rachel Dratch Rachel Tucker
Sara Ramirez Timothy Hughes Victoria Clark Zachary Noah Piser
CORE - Director/Choreographer
Anna D. Shapiro Danny Mefford Ellenore Scott
CORE - Writers/Composers
Charles Busch John Weidman Mary Rodgers Rob Berman
CORE - Shows
Caroline, or Change for colored girls…
Funny Girl (2022 Revival) Into the Woods (2022 Revival)
Kimberly Akimbo Mr. Saturday Night Nine POTUS
The Music Man (2022 Revival)
CORE - Iconic Roles
Bernadette Peters Danny Burstein Nathan Lane Patti LuPone Sutton Foster
RARE - Golden Age Bob Merrill Sammy Davis, Jr.
RARE - Theaters James Earl Jones
2019 SERIES CORE CARDS - WRITERS/COMPOSERS
2019 SERIES CORE CARDS - DIRECTORS/CHOREOGRAPHERS
2019 SERIES CORE CARDS - SHOWS
Angie Schworer Beth Leavel Brooks Ashmanskas Courtenay Collins
THE PROM
Emma and Alyssa (lenticular) Protest Signs (lenticular) Tiara (foil)
AUTUMN 2017 CORE CARDS - PERFORMERS
Annie Golden B.D. Wong Barrett Doss Bebe Neuwith Beth Fowler
Caroline O'Connor Chuck Cooper Gary Beach Greg Hildreth Gregory Hines
42nd Street Ain't Misbehavin' Angels in America Avenue Q Bandstand
Beauty and the Beast Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Hello, Dolly! (2017)
David Cromer Julie Taymor Kenny Leon Michael Arden
SPRING 2018 CORE CARDS - PERFORMERS
Angie Schworer Boyd Gaines Daniel Breaker Denzel Washington
SPRING 2018 CORE CARDS - SHOWS
AUTUMN 2018 CORE CARDS - PERFORMERS
Alex Boniello Ari'el Stachel Austin Pendleton Bonnie Milligan Caesar Samayoa
Capathia Jenkins George Salazar Gerard Canonico Grey Hensen Howard McGillin
Applause Brigadoon Hair Head Over Heels
The Full Monty The Iceman Cometh The Prom
AUTUMN 2018 CORE CARDS - DIRECTORS/CHOREOGRAPHERS
WRITERS/COMPOSERS
Baayork Lee Mike Nichols Charles Strouse Douglas Carter Beane
Quiara Alegria Hudes R. Maltby and D. Shire Young Jean Lee
2022 CARD SERIES
Broadway Massacre of 1982 (R)
John Golden (R) Nederlander (R) Empire (demolished) (R)
“Broadway Baby” “The Ladies Who Lunch” “Our Time"
Patti LuPone (SR) Pulitzer Musicals (SR) Sondheim Celebration (SR)
Wonderstudy (SR)
Andre De Shields (SR) George Salazar (SR) The Prom (SR) Tootsie (SR)
Al Hirschfeld (SR) Ghost Light (foil) (SR) Times Square (foil) (SR)
AUTUMN 2017
C. Altomare/D. Klena (SR) Lillias White (SR) Mandy Gonzalez (SR) Telly Leung (SR)
SPRING 2018
Jule Styne (R)
The Greatest Showman (foil) (SR) Carolee Carmello (SR) Katrina Lenk (SR)
Lesli Margherita and Stewie (SR)
AUTUMN 2018
Audra McDonald (SR) Iain Armitage (SR) Marin Mazzie and Jason Danieley (SR)
