Theatre Book Review: I'm the Greatest Star: Broadway's Top Musical Legends from 1900 to Today. By Robert Viagas. Published by Applause Theatre & Cinema Books. Copyright 2009. Hardcover. 450 pages.
I just got another great theatre book - I have great friends who know what I love and Christmas came early this year! This huge book is another must-have for musical theatre lovers and theatre history fans. And if you love a particular Broadway superstar, this book is also for you.
Written by Playbill Online founder and editor Robert Viagas, I'm the Greatest Star: Broadway's Top Musical Legends from 1900 to Today offers fair treatment - he not only covers the highlights, but also the stumbling blocks - of the careers of 40 Broadway stars (39 chapters, with Fred and Adele Astaire sharing a chapter). For example, the author very candidly discusses the racism faced by Bert Williams, the first Black (he was not African-American) performer to break the color barrier on Broadway, often appearing in his own acts or as a part of the Ziegfeld Follies. Viagas also discusses the media backlash against Donna Murphy, who at one time made the New York Times for failure to appear in Wonderful Town; ultimately, the truth was she suffered from a series of tragic miscarriages, but for awhile she was the negative talk of the town. He tells of his first-hand experience at the infamous Julie Andrews press conference/post show media lashing over the "egregiously overlooked" Victor/Victoria. The book is full of such juicy tidbits.
Of particular interest to historians will be the chapters on Ethel Waters, Bert Lahr, Ray Bolger and Zero Mostel, for there isn't much out there in one place about these folks. For the younger set who might have heard of, but aren't that familiar with some stars, the chapters on Jerry Orbach (who did much more than Law & Order), Donna McKechnie (who did much more than A Chorus Line), and Ethel Merman (who did much more than Gypsy) will be of interest. And of course, most everyone will be interested in chapters of those legends who still work, like Chita Rivera, Angela Lansbury, Christine Ebersole, Audra McDonald and Sutton Foster.
Wicked fans will have to debate amongst themselves as to whether Viagas chose the right diva as "legend," in choosing Kristin Chenoweth (if you asked me today, I'd say he made the right choice in terms of Broadway star power). But, as with all of the really modern choices, only time will really tell if they have all earned their place in the book. And while I agree with most of his choices, I really have to question the inclusion of Brian Stokes-Mitchell. Is he a terrific performer? Sure. But legendary? I'm not so sure. I can think of several actors with similar resumes that aren't included and rightfully so (Howard McGillin comes to mind immediately) because they are great stars of the Broadway stage, hard-working, with careers in the theatre. But they aren't superstar/legend types. By his own definition, Viagas describes a star as someone who could be wearing a sack, and yet, when they walk into a room, they command attention and respect (I'm paraphrasing here). And I also have to ask: Christine Ebersole, but NOT Betty Buckley or Liza Minelli or Harvey Fierstein? I also find myself wondering who might be added in furture volumes. Cheyenne Jackson? Alice Ripley? Matt Cavenaugh? Laura Benanti? Michael Cerveris? Gavin Creel? Time will tell!
If there is a downside to this volume, it is that there is a lack of photographs. Each chapter starts with a full page image of the star in a show. The pictures included are interesting and not typical - Ebersole in 1980's Camelot, Tommy Tune in the national tour of Bye Bye Birdie are but two fun photos. But it would be nice to see some shots of these people doing what they do best throughout each chapter.
Also, there are a few errors in facts that I found, most likely editing errors (which I know plenty about, myself - thank you readers!). For example, Chita Rivera won the Tony on 1993, not 1991 for Kiss of the Spider Woman, and while Angela Lansbury did win the Tony for Mame in 1966, the show itself did NOT win the Tony for Best Musical. That honor went to Man of La Mancha, a fact not mentioned in the chapter about Richard Kiley. Factual blips aside, it is clear that Mr. Viagas reveres his subjects, affection for each as obvious as his respect for each.
Finally, the price on this book - did I mention it is huge and hardcover? - is a mere $29.95. (Amazon.com has it for $19.79!) In a day and age where a paperback can be $15.00, even $30.00 for a hardcover full reference book is really not much.
Comments? Leave on here or write to me at email@example.com
HERE'S WHAT'S NEW ON THE SITE:
CLICK/TAP THE TABS ABOVE TO ACCESS OUR ARCHIVE OF SHOW AND MEDIA REVIEWS, AS WELL AS FEATURES LIKE MR. AND MS. BROADWAY, STANDING @ ZERO AND ONE THAT GOT AWAY. COLLECTORS WILL BE INTERESTED IN OUR LIGHTS OF BROADWAY CARDS AND PLAYBILLS FOR SALE!
COMING UP ON BROADWAY: SIX - Opens Company - Previews Diana - Previews The Lehman Trilogy - Previews Mrs. Doubtfire - Previews The Minutes - Previews MJ: The Musical - Previews 9.21 Plaza Suite - Previews TBA American Buffalo - Previews TBA Take Me Out - Previews 3.22.21 The Music Man - Previews 12.20.21 1776 - Previews TBA Caroline, or Change -Previews TBA Flying Over Sunset - Fall 2021 Our Town - TBA Birthday Candles - Fall 2021 Sing Street -Winter 2021
COMING UP THIS WEEK: 10/26: 1990s Broadway Musical Logo Madness! The Big 32: Elton John Region - 10/27: Mr. Broadway October 2020 - 10/28: Musical of the Month: Hairspray: The Films - 10/29: Ms. Broadway October 2020 - 10/30: The Broadway Game of the Week
Contact us: firstname.lastname@example.org (Email); @jkstheatrescene (Twitter); jkstheatrescene (Instagram)
WE'VE ADDED MORE 2019 AND MEGAMIX LIGHTS OF BROADWAY CARDS FOR SALE OR TRADE!