There were so many great things happening in on and off Broadway scene, it was really difficult to select just one winner in many categories in this Best of the Best Performances list. Of course, a lot of this list is only semi-serious and meant to be fun. I'll get a little more serious when I give you my 20 Movers and Shakers list, which names those theatre folk who really made a big impact on Thursday, and when I name my 10 Best Shows (and 5 biggest disappointments) on Monday. But for now, let's have a little seriousness and a little bit of fun!
1. Best Debut (Play): Zachary Quinto, The Glass Menagerie – His performance is fierce, unsettling, and profoundly affecting. I'm already looking forward to seeing him in his next show!
2. Best Debut (Musical): Zachary Levi, First Date – The TV star is a Broadway musical natural! What a voice, and what nice chemistry with Krysta Rodriguez!
3. Best Child Actor: Milly Shapiro, Matilda – She's adorable and legitimately excellent, and one hell of a dynamo!
4. Most Under-Appreciated Actor: Stark Sands, Kinky Boots – Despite a Tony nod (which surprised everyone, including Stark Sands), people seem to forget that his Charlie is the other half of the emotional center of the show.
5. Most Under-Appreciated Actress: Jessica Hecht, The Assembled Parties – She got lost in the storm called Judith Light, but her wounded aging mother act was unforgettable.
6. Most Under-Appreciated Cast: Hands on a Hardbody – Even the truck was awesome. But nobody showed up. Your loss. Truly.
7. Best Chemistry:TIE: Casey and Aaron, Krysta Rodriguez and Zachary Levi, First Date and Ella and Topher, Laura Osnes and Santino Fontana, Cinderella and Chauncey and Ned, Nathan Lane and Jonny Orsini, The Nance. If you any saw them, you'd know that no explanation is necessary.
8. Best Cast Chemistry: The Nance – Fighting society takes a unified group... a family. This cast fought "the man" as one, and the play (and we) was all the better for it.
9. The Grin-and-Bear-It Award (Cast): Soul Doctor – Just as I said for last year's winner: I’m embarrassed for them. But they still showed up for 8 a week and gave it 100%.
10. The Grin-and-Bear-It Award (Individual): Kate Baldwin, Big Fish – Her show's a dull one, and she still managed to shine through all the special effects and mediocrity.
12. Best New Song Written for a Broadway Musical: “When I Grow Up” from Matilda
13. Best New Song Written for an Off-Broadway Musical: TIE: “Changing My Major” and “Ring of Keys” both from Fun Home
14. Best Underscoring: The Glass Menagerie
16. Best Props in a Musical: Pippin – As endlessly inventive as the entire production.
17. Best Body Part: Just like last year: Legs! – But this time I'm talking actual legs, like all the pairs in all of those amazing Kinky Boots!
20. Best Underwear (Play): Billy Magnussen in Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike
19. Best Kiss (Lesbian): Medium Alison and Joan in Fun Home A first kiss was never more life-changing or honest...
21. Best Underwear (Musical): Rachel Bay Jones in a slip in the final moments of Pippin...
22. Best Shirtless Moment: Matthew James Thomas in Pippin – Why isn't that on the Broadway poster?
24. Best Villain (Male): Monty Navarro (Bryce Pinkham - he won last year, too!) in A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder – Who knew love and murder could be so deliciously evil.
25. Best Villain (Female?): Miss Trunchbull (Bertie Carvel) in Matilda: The Musical – Cold. Ruthless. Funny as Hell.
26. Best Bathroom Scene: Joshua, Buddy and Uncle Frank (Wesley Taylor, Josh Lamon and Rory O'Malley) in the rest stop men's room in Little Miss Sunshine Such drama... and real urinals, too!
28. Best Victor/Victoria (Play): Viola/Cesario (Samuel Barnett in Twelfth Night)
29. In the Heights Award for Best Use of a Cell Phone: First Date
30. Best Peter Parker Rise Above Award: Amber Imam in Soul Doctor – The best thing about the show...
32. The 70,Girls,70 Award for Best Grandma: Andrea Martin in Pippin
33. The “Say a Little Prayer” Award for Too Much of a Good Thing: PLEASE… enough girl groups and dead rock stars already!
34. The Alice Ripley Award for Acting Intensity: Michael Cerveris in Fun Home. The actor was barely recognizable in a career-making role.
35. The Scottsboro Boys Award for Too Short a Run: Hands on a Hardbody
36. The Baby It’s You/Shirelles Award for Back Up Singer Excellence: The entire company of After Midnight.
- Check out all things 2013 in Review by clicking on the "Year in Review" tab at the top!